Funding opportunities
Use of Human Neural Stem Cells for Neuroprotection Following Hypothermia In Sub-acute Neonatal
Funding Type:
Disease Team Therapy Planning I
Grant Number:
DR2-05279
Funds Committed:
$81,406
Funding Recommendations:
Recommended
Public Abstract:
Neonatal hypoxic-ischemic injury (HII) (annually ~1700/California & 13,000/US) remains a devastating cause of brain injury resulting in long-term disability (cerebral palsy, mental retardation, epilepsy). Approximately 80% of newborns surviving severe HII are severely impaired and 20% are moderately impaired. It is estimated that the lifetime national costs for persons with mental retardation approaches $51.2 billion and for those affected with cerebral palsy it is $11.5 billion. In many individuals, the etiology is traceable to neonatal HII. The costs of care for a family with these disabilities are prohibitively expensive: it is estimated that the average lifetime additional expenses for an individual with cerebral palsy is ~$921,000. As a result, many newborns with moderate & severe HII have life-long needs for chronic medical and rehabilitative care that in California. is funded by the Dept. of Health Care Services and agencies such as Cal. Children’s Services, Cal. Med. Assistance Program., and the Child Health & Disability Prevention Program. Although hypothermia (HT) has become the standard-of-care treatment for newborns with HII, it must be initiated within hours after birth (making it unfeasible for many newborns), and is only modestly effective in moderate HII & totally ineffective in severe HII. There is a dire need for developing better (& later) treatments that more elegantly target injury processes and pathways that together result in brain damage. Although many agents have been tried, there remain no effective treatments for global or focal ischemic injury in adults or children. Neural stem cells (NSCs) have proven effective in rodent models of HII based on multiple mechanisms leading to several clinical trials in adult stroke. We believe the combination of HT and NSCs may act together because of overlap in their respective reparative mechanisms. This clinical trial will be done at 8 California newborn intensive care units over a 4 year period. We will evaluate term newborns who have suffered HII and undergone therapeutic HT. In half of eligible newborns, NSCs will be implanted by a neurosurgeon into the ventricles of the brain using special endoscopic equipment. These infants will undergo frequent pediatric, neurological and neuropsychological examinations as well as studies using magnetic resonance imaging until study completion at 18 months of life. Our objective is to show that implantation of stem cells into newborns with HII who undergo HT will have better long-term neurological outcomes than newborns who did not receive stem cells. If successful, we can then pursue larger clinical trials nationwide. This hopefully will provide a treatment that could dramatically reduce the morbidity associated with neonatal HII. The potential social and economic benefits to affected children, their families and society would be enormous.
Statement of Benefit to California:
Neonatal hypoxic-ischemic injury (HII) (annually ~1700/California & 13,000/US) remains a devastating cause of brain injury resulting in long-term disability (cerebral palsy, mental retardation, epilepsy). The majority of newborns surviving severe HII are severely impaired and the costs of care for a family with these disabilities are prohibitively expensive: it is estimated that the average lifetime additional expenses for an individual with cerebral palsy is ~$921,000. As a result, many newborns with moderate & severe HII have life-long needs for chronic medical and rehabilitative care that in California is funded by the Department. of Health Care Services and agencies such as California Children’s Services, California. MEDI-CAL. Assistance Program and the Child Health & Disability Prevention Program. Treatment of newborns with HII consists of using therapeutic hypothermia (HT) which has become the standard-of-care. However, it must be initiated within hours after birth. There is a strong need for developing better treatments that target injury processes and pathways that together result in brain damage. Neural stem cells (NSCs) have proven effective in rodent models of HII based on multiple mechanisms leading to several clinical trials in adult stroke. We believe the combination of HT and NSCs may act together because of overlap in their respective reparative mechanisms. This clinical trial will be done at 8 California newborn intensive care units over a 4 year period. We will evaluate term newborns who have suffered HII and undergone therapeutic HT. In half of eligible newborns, NSCs will be implanted by a neurosurgeon into the ventricles of the brain using special endoscopic equipment. These infants will undergo frequent pediatric, neurological and neuropsychological examinations as well as studies using magnetic resonance imaging until study completion at 18 months of life. Our objective is to show that implantation of stem cells into newborns with HII who undergo HT will have better long-term neurological outcomes than newborns who did not receive stem cells. If successful, we can then pursue larger clinical trials nationwide. This hopefully will provide a treatment that could dramatically reduce the brain injury associated with neonatal HII. The potential social and economic benefits to affected children, their families and society would be enormous. The proposed research will be of great benefit to the citizens of California as it has the potential to substantially reduce the severity of neurological disability in neonates who suffered severe birth asphyxia which would result in improved quality of life, reduced medical and rehabilitation costs and provide the opportunity for affected children to become more independent and benefit from educational and training opportunities and programs offered by our state government.
Review Summary:
Project Synopsis:
This Planning Award proposal focuses on the use of human neural stem cells (NSCs) in conjunction with hypothermia treatment (HT) to treat hypoxic ischemic injury (HII). Neonatal HII is a leading cause of brain injury in newborns and can result in cerebral palsy, mental retardation and epilepsy. For the Research Award, the applicant proposes one year of preclinical studies followed by an IND submission and a Phase I clinical trial over the final three years.
Significance and Impact:
- Cell therapy could have a significant impact on the treatment of HII.
- There is a great need for new therapies for HII that could supplement the benefit provided by HT. If successful, this project could change the standard of care and reduce the number and severity of cases of cerebral palsy.
Project Rationale and Feasibility:
- Reviewers found that the proposal contained insufficient preliminary data to support the combination therapeutic regimen of HT and NSCs. Specifically, proof-of-concept data for the combination are lacking.
- The proposed Phase I trial is overly aggressive for a first-in-human study and the patient enrollment goals are not reasonable or feasible. As the purpose of Phase I trials is evaluating safety, fewer subjects and fewer investigational sites are warranted.
- The proposed broad range of patient injury severity is not appropriate for a Phase I trial. Specifically, reviewers suggested that severe cases, potentially even those not eligible for HT, may be the most appropriate to assess safety of NSC therapy. However, they noted that moderate cases might be the best indication to test for efficacy.
- It is not clear how easily dosing, either the number of days of HT or of NSCs, will translate from rats to human neonates. Reviewers suggested dosing experiments be performed in an established large animal model.
- Reviewers raised questions about the proposed NSCs and their comparability to other NSCs that have been used in clinical trials.
- One reviewer had reservations about the proposed animal model and pointed out that, while the model has many advantages, it does not reproduce what happens to term human infants with hypoxic-ischemic injury following birth asphyxia.
- Despite these significant criticisms, reviewers agreed that there is a strong rationale for pursuing stem cell therapy for HII.
Principal Investigator (PI) and Planning Leader:
- Although the PI has some experience in clinical trials, it is not clear that s/he has specific experience submitting INDs or leading clinical trials.
- The PI has expertise related to HII and traumatic brain injury in children, specifically imaging of neurological injury, which is especially relevant to this application.
- The planning leader has relevant experience in animal models and imaging of brain injury of various types, and is suitable for this position.
Conflicts:


